Why Pet Screening Is Always a Good Idea

Damian Bennett • October 19, 2023

Americans are a nation of pet owners. According to Statista.com, in 2023 about 66 percent of American households are pet owners. The number keeps rising each year.


With that in mind, as a landlord, it makes sense to provide a pet-friendly rental. You may be able to charge more rent, attract a larger pool of tenants, improve retention rates, and attract responsible tenants.


That said, having a pet in your rental isn’t without its fair share of risks. Pets are known for scratching and clawing at furniture. Dogs also love to chew on furniture, carpets, and even electrical cords. Other types of pet damage include stained carpets, and digging of holes in the yard.


Fortunately for landlords, you won’t have to deal with such pet issues like excessive barking if you implement a proper pet screening process. Keep reading to know the answers to commonly asked questions regarding pet screening.

As a landlord, having a pet in your rental has many benefits for you. We made a small list of them for you.

Why Should Landlords Allow Pets in Their Rental Property? 

Larger Pool of Tenants

According to a survey made by the American Pet Products Association, 86.9 million U.S. households own a pet. This means that a significant portion of renters are looking for a pet-friendly rental. As such, by having a pet friendly rental, you’ll be able to attract more prospective tenants.

Higher Rent and Longer Tenancies

There is a high demand for pet-friendly rentals. And the higher the demand, the more rent you can charge for your pet-friendly unit. What’s more, studies have found that tenants with a pet tend to stay in rental units for longer periods of time compared to those without.

a hand holding a dog's paw

Responsible Tenants

Generally speaking, tenants who are a responsible pet owner are more responsible than those without a pet. And because they are responsible for their pet’s behavior, they are also more likely to take good care of their rental.

What Is Pet Screening?

The pet screening process is similar to tenant screening. Pet screening allows landlord to evaluate the risk of allowing pets into your property. You will be able to know more about the pet’s health, personality, and behavior.


To conduct an effective pet-screening process, you must do several things. For one, you have to create a pet screening questionnaire. The following are some of the pet screening questions you will want to ask the prospective tenants on the pet screening application:


  • What animal and breed is your pet?
  • How much does your pet weigh?
  • How long have you had this pet?
  • Is your pet vaccinated? If so, can you provide the proof?
  • Has your pet ever caused harm to another person or pet?
  • Does your pet have behavioral issues?
  • Is the pet housetrained?



In addition to requiring a pet screening questionnaire, you may also want to conduct an in-person pet interview. During pet interview, you want to look for things like the pet's body language, behavior, and overall health.


That said, please keep in mind that the pet may get nervous around new people. As such, the initial interaction may not provide a perfect reflection of their behavior.

a vet and a volunteer looking at a dog's face wearing blue masks and the doctor has gloves while the volunteer is reassuring him

What Clauses Should You Include in the Lease Agreement When It Comes to Pets?

As a landlord, it’s important to have a pet-screening policy to help protect your property and other tenants. The following are some of the things that you should consider including in the pet policies:


·  The type and breed of pet allowed into the rental property.

·  The weight of the pet .

·  A requirement that the pet be up to date on their vaccinations.

·  A requirement that the pet have insurance.

·  A requirement that the tenant pay a pet deposit.

What About Emotional Support Animals?

Service and emotional support animals have certain special protections under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Federal Fair Housing Act (FHA). The following are some things you cannot do when interacting with tenants and their service or emotional support animals:


·  Treat the tenant differently because they have assistance animals. For instance, try to evict them based on having service animals.

·  Charge the tenant a deposit or a pet fee for having the emotional support pet.

·  Refuse to rent to the tenant because of their pet’s weight, or training and certification.

·  Require the tenant to keep their service animals in a particular way, such as in a kennel or crate.


owner walking with their golden retriever on a leash

Additionally, you must provide the tenant with reasonable accommodations and allow their requests for reasonable modifications. Examples of reasonable accommodations that you can provide the tenant with include the following:


·  Waiving pet rent or pet security deposit.

·  Removing restrictions on the breed or weight of a pet.

·  Allowing the tenant to keep the service animal in any area, including common areas such as the swimming pool or laundry room.

·  Allowing a tenant with service animals even with a “no-pets” policy.


Examples of reasonable modifications that you may be required to make include the following.


·  Installing a ramp to the front door of the apartment.

·  Widening the doorway to the bathroom to allow the support animal to pass through.


Of course, the specific accommodations and modifications will vary on the specific needs of the tenant and their emotional support animal.

Conclusion

Pet screening is always a good idea when allowing a pet into your rental property. Among other things, you may be able to reduce the risk of property damage, protect the safety of tenants and other neighbors, and reduce the risk of pet-related nuisance complaints.


If you need expert help in managing your rental property, First & Main Property Management can help. We are a trusted property management company in Napa, California. Get in touch to learn more!

By Damian Bennett July 7, 2025
First & Main Property Management shows how clear, consistent communication with tenants and owners improves retention, reduces issues, and drives long-term success.
By Damian Bennett July 7, 2025
First & Main Property Management explains landlord responsibilities for service and emotional support animals. Stay compliant with fair housing laws and avoid legal issues.
By Damian Bennett June 3, 2025
Effective tenant communication is key to preventing costly repairs and maintaining safe, well-managed properties. Discover how First & Main Property Management helps creates timely maintenance reporting to protect your investment and keep tenants satisfied.
By Damian Bennett June 3, 2025
Discover essential strategies for foreign investors to manage U.S. real estate remotely. Learn about hiring property managers, legal and tax considerations, entity structures, and maximizing returns with expert support from First & Main Property Management.
By Damian Bennett May 13, 2025
Key Takeaways Maintain Property Appeal: Regular upkeep, aesthetic improvements, and preventive maintenance help attract quality tenants and reduce vacancy periods. Set Competitive Prices: Conduct market research to set the right rental price, offering move-in specials during slower seasons to attract tenants quickly. Leverage Professional Help: Partnering with a property management company like First & Main Property Management ensures efficient leasing, effective marketing, and better tenant retention. How much is an empty rental unit costing you? Vacancy rates are a key metric for property owners, and every day a unit sits vacant means lost income, rising maintenance costs, and potential security risks. At First & Main Property Management , we understand that reducing vacancies is crucial for maximizing your rental income and ensuring the long-term success of your investment. By effectively managing your property and attracting the right tenants, we help you keep your units filled and your business thriving. Keep reading to learn more!
By Damian Bennett May 7, 2025
Learn how clear, consistent communication with tenants can prevent disputes, protect your property, and streamline your rental operations. Discover practical tips from First & Main Property Management.
By Damian Bennett April 8, 2025
Discover how the DOJ's new real estate commission ruling affects landlords and property transactions. First & Main Property Management explains the changes and what they mean for your investments.
By Damian Bennett April 2, 2025
Learn essential tenant privacy practices with First & Main Property Management. Ensure legal compliance, protect sensitive data, and maintain positive tenant relationships with these expert tips.
By Damian Bennett March 11, 2025
Learn how to protect your rental property from scams with expert tips from First & Main Property Management. Discover effective strategies for tenant screening, secure rent collection, and fraud prevention to safeguard your investment.
By Damian Bennett March 11, 2025
Discover effective strategies for successful out-of-state rental property investments with First & Main Property Management. Learn how to diversify your portfolio, access affordable markets, and maximize returns with expert guidance.